image

Ninth Circuit Revives Lawsuit Over Revoked Concealed Carry License in San Diego

CaliforniaCourts & Legislation
Ninth Circuit Revives Lawsuit Over Revoked Concealed Carry License in San Diego

A federal appeals court has revived a constitutional lawsuit filed by a Chula Vista resident against San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez and San Diego County after his concealed carry weapon permit was revoked. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that a lower court erred when it dismissed the action, which challenges the sheriff’s decision to cancel the permit based on the gun owner’s membership in a motorcycle club.

Kenneth Shilling, a longtime employee of the Chula Vista Elementary School District with no criminal history, received his concealed carry permit in June 2022 under a previous sheriff. However, Sheriff Martinez revoked the license in December 2023 under a former provision in the California penal code requiring good moral character. The sheriff cited Shilling’s association with the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, which she viewed as a criminal street gang.

Revocation Based on Group Association

In his complaint filed in June 2024, Shilling contested the sheriff’s characterization of the motorcycle club. He explained that the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club was established in Los Angeles in 1946 by returning World War II veterans focused on a shared love of riding. The lawsuit states that the organization participates in charitable events and has never been classified as a criminal street gang or an outlaw club operating outside mainstream riding.

Shilling argued that revoking his permit due to his group membership violated his First Amendment right to free association and infringed on his Second Amendment rights. The lower court dismissed the claim after concluding Shilling had to prove the revocation physically stopped him from participating in club activities. Writing for the unanimous panel, U.S. Circuit Judge Patrick Bumatay rejected that reasoning, explaining that free association rights can be infringed in varied ways when tied to the loss of a constitutional right.

Key Events in the San Diego Concealed Carry Case
  1. Concealed carry permit issued under previous sheriff.
  2. Sheriff Martinez revokes permit under moral character clause.
  3. California replaces moral character rule with objective standards.
  4. Lawsuit filed against Sheriff Martinez and San Diego County.
  5. Ninth Circuit panel unanimously revives the constitutional lawsuit.

Source: Courthouse News Service

County Policy Versus State Law

The Ninth Circuit panel emphasized that San Diego County officials were acting as local policymakers rather than executing state law when they used club membership as grounds for license revocation. The court noted that no California statute mandated that county-specific standard. Circuit Judges Kenneth Lee and Jennifer Sung joined Judge Bumatay in the decision.

California replaced its good moral character requirement with objective and defined criteria in January 2024, following the U.S. Supreme Court decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. Although state law has since changed, the Ninth Circuit’s ruling allows Shilling to proceed with his lawsuit over the county’s former policy.

What This Decision Means for Gun Owners

This ruling signals that local authorities cannot automatically treat membership in a lawful community or social group as a valid reason to strip away constitutional rights. For ordinary citizens in California, the decision reinforces the legal shift away from subjective, county-by-county standards for concealed carry permits.

While California now uses objective statutory criteria for permit evaluations, individuals who suffered permit denials or revocations under earlier local policies may still have legal remedies if their constitutional rights were improperly infringed by local officials.

Video explainer: This is why the Supreme Court ruling on concealed carry matters — Fox News

When to Speak With an Attorney

If your concealed carry license was denied or revoked based on group affiliations or subjective character evaluations, speaking with an attorney experienced in constitutional law can help clarify your options. A lawyer can evaluate whether local officials exceeded their legal authority and assist in challenging improper permit actions.

What this means: our conclusions

1 Good news1 What to watch1 Context1 What to do
  1. Good newsProtections for Group Membership

    The decision prevents local authorities from using lawful group associations as a sole pretext to deny or revoke firearm permits.

  2. ContextLimits on Local Sheriff Discretion

    Sheriffs acting as local policymakers cannot create subjective rules that deprive residents of underlying constitutional protections.

  3. What to watchImpact of Objective Standard Changes

    California's adoption of objective permit criteria reduces arbitrary decisions, though lawsuits over past revocations continue.

  4. What to doReviewing Past Permit Decisions

    Gun owners who had permits revoked under old subjective standards should check whether local policies infringed on their rights.

Comparison of CCW License Standards and Policies
FeatureSan Diego County RevocationCalifornia Law Post-January 2024
Evaluation StandardSubjective 'good moral character' clauseDefined and objective criteria
Basis for ActionAssociation with Boozefighters Motorcycle ClubSpecific statutory criteria
Policy AuthorityCounty-specific definition by sheriffStatewide objective standard

Source: Courthouse News Service

Primary sources & the law

This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 21, 2026.

Source: Courthouse News Service

More from California

Find a lawyer in California

Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in California by practice area.