image

Amazon Lawsuit Against AI Browser Comet Paused as Judge Considers Dismissal

CaliforniaIP & Technology
Amazon Lawsuit Against AI Browser Comet Paused as Judge Considers Dismissal

A federal judge in San Francisco has put evidence gathering on hold in Amazon’s lawsuit against Perplexity AI, the developer behind the Comet artificial intelligence web browser. Senior U.S. District Judge Maxine Chesney granted Perplexity’s request for a temporary stay in discovery following a three-hour hearing on Friday, giving the court time to evaluate a motion to dismiss the lawsuit.

The dispute centers on Comet, an AI web browser capable of searching the internet, comparing prices and reviews, and completing purchases on Amazon. Amazon filed suit alleging the tool breaches the U.S. Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and California’s Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act by accessing its servers without authorization. However, a recent federal appeals court decision overturned earlier findings in Amazon’s favor, forcing the lower court to reconsider the case.

Appeals Court Focuses on User Control

Judge Chesney previously found that Amazon was likely to succeed on its claims that the AI tool accessed its systems without permission. However, a three-judge panel on the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected those findings and sent the case back to her court. The appellate panel concluded that the trial court erred in its analysis of statutory rules prohibiting unauthorized computer access.

Writing for the Ninth Circuit panel, U.S. Circuit Judge Milan Smith Jr. explained that “it is the user who ‘accesses’ Amazon’s computers with the help of the assistant.” The appellate court applied the same reasoning to defeat Amazon’s state-level computer data claim, holding that automated software operating at a user’s direction does not inherently access servers unlawfully.

Key Arguments in Amazon v. Perplexity AI
Amazon's Claims
  • Comet acts as a rogue actor entering servers without permission
  • Updated browser version navigates to Amazon without direct invitation
  • Perplexity employees tested versions of Comet using personal accounts
Perplexity's Defense
  • Users must authorize their own Amazon accounts for Comet to work
  • Ninth Circuit ruled that users direct the assistant's access
  • Employee testing using personal accounts does not constitute computer fraud

Source: Courthouse News Service

Amazon Points to Updated Software and Employee Testing

During Friday’s hearing, Amazon argued that the Ninth Circuit decision relied on an incomplete understanding of how Comet functions. Amazon’s attorney told the judge that Perplexity released an updated version of Comet after the appellate ruling, which Amazon claims operates with greater autonomy than the court originally reviewed.

According to Amazon’s counsel, a user can simply request that Comet buy an item, and the tool will navigate to Amazon without being explicitly invited in. Characterizing Perplexity as a rogue actor violating Amazon’s automated software restrictions, Amazon also cited allegations that Perplexity employees had tested versions of Comet on Amazon using their personal accounts.

Defense Argues User Direction Remains Essential

Attorneys representing Perplexity pushed back against claims that the core facts of the legal dispute had changed. Perplexity’s counsel told the court that Comet cannot access Amazon independently, explaining that a user must actively connect their personal Amazon account to grant the tool access.

Perplexity argued that user direction remains the essential underpinning of the Ninth Circuit’s decision. Defense attorneys also addressed allegations regarding employee testing, asserting that if standard account usage by individual employees were treated as criminal conduct, it would directly conflict with the appellate court’s holding.

Video explainer: US Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) — Udacity

What This Litigation Means for Everyday Tech Users

This lawsuit addresses a growing legal question for consumers who use AI tools and automated web extensions for everyday tasks like online shopping. As AI browser assistants become more common, courts are defining whether automated software operates as an independent actor or merely as an extension of the individual user.

If courts adopt Amazon’s view, major online retailers could gain broader legal authority to block third-party shopping assistants or restrict users from linking automated browsers to their accounts. If courts maintain the Ninth Circuit’s approach, consumers will retain greater freedom to use AI software to automate routine browsing and price checks. For now, the stay in discovery pauses formal evidence exchange while Judge Chesney evaluates whether Amazon’s lawsuit should be dismissed entirely.

If you operate an online platform or develop software that interacts with commercial websites, consulting an intellectual property or technology attorney can help you understand computer fraud laws and platform terms of service.

What this means: our conclusions

1 Risk1 What to watch1 Context1 What to do
  1. What to watchPending ruling on motion to dismiss

    The trial judge will decide whether Amazon's new factual arguments justify continuing the lawsuit or if appellate precedent requires full dismissal.

  2. ContextStandard for user-directed AI software

    The Ninth Circuit ruling reinforces that automated tools operating under direct consumer instruction generally reflect user access under federal computer fraud laws.

  3. RiskRisk of tighter e-commerce restrictions

    If platforms successfully challenge automated assistants, consumers may face limited access to third-party price comparison tools on major shopping sites.

  4. What to doCheck third-party application permissions

    Users linking automated AI tools to personal shopping accounts should review platform terms of service and account authorization settings.

Overview of Parties' Legal Positions
IssueAmazon's PositionPerplexity's Position
Server AccessComet acts autonomously without explicit invitation to enter Amazon.Comet cannot access Amazon unless a user links their personal account.
Appeals Court ImpactAppeals panel lacked facts on newer Comet software and employee testing.Ninth Circuit established that users, not the software, access the site.
Statutory ComplianceComet violates federal and California computer access restrictions.User-directed account usage does not constitute unauthorized access.

Source: Courthouse News Service

This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 21, 2026.

Source: Courthouse News Service

More from California

Find a lawyer in California

Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in California by practice area.