image

State Attorneys General Oppose Federal Effort to Regulate Sports and Election Betting

State Attorneys General Oppose Federal Effort to Regulate Sports and Election Betting

New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general are opposing two federal rules that would give the Commodity Futures Trading Commission exclusive authority over online prediction markets. The coalition filed formal comment letters opposing the federal agency’s effort to oversee sports wagering, election betting, and similar event contracts.

State leaders argue the federal agency is overstepping its legal mandate and attempting to override long-standing state authority to regulate gambling and protect consumers. Prediction markets such as Kalshi and Polymarket allow users to place wagers on game winners, point spreads, player statistics, and election outcomes. These platforms contend that because they operate as contract markets under federal oversight, state gambling regulations do not apply to them.

How the CFTC Wants to Redefine Financial Swaps

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) oversees U.S. financial markets where traders buy and sell contracts tied to future prices of commodities like oil, wheat, interest rates, and foreign currencies. These transactions include “swaps,” which are agreements where two parties exchange payments based on changes in the value of an underlying asset or rate. The CFTC has not historically regulated gambling or contracts used for entertainment.

To assert federal oversight over prediction markets, the CFTC is pursuing two distinct rules that alter the legal definition of a swap:

  • Interim Rule: Currently in effect, this rule distinguishes between house-backed casino games and games where users wager against each other. Under this interim rule, only house-backed casino-style games are classified as traditional gambling products excluded from being swaps.
  • Proposed Rule: Not yet in effect, this proposal expands the definition of a swap to cover peer-to-peer sports and election betting. The CFTC argues that defining these bets as swaps gives the federal agency exclusive regulation, displacing state control.
Coalition Support Against CFTC Gambling Rules
44Attorneys general opposing CFTC rulemakings
39States supporting New Jersey's Supreme Court petition
146Tribal nations and organizations backing the petition

Source: New Jersey Attorney General

Why State Attorneys General Are Objecting

The coalition of 44 attorneys general contends that regulating gambling falls directly within the traditional police powers of the states. In their comment letters, the state officials argued that Congress never gave the CFTC legal authority to manage gambling harms. The attorneys general also stated that the federal agency skipped required rulemaking steps and exceeded the statutory power granted by Congress.

The dispute is also playing out in federal courts. New Jersey has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear its lawsuit against the prediction platform Kalshi. That petition is supported by 39 states, the District of Columbia, and 146 tribal nations and tribal organizations. According to state officials, the majority of federal courts that have considered the issue have rejected claims that prediction markets offering sports betting are exempt from state law.

What This Dispute Means for Online Bettors

For consumers using online prediction markets or sports wagering apps, the outcome of this federal dispute determines which regulatory protections apply to their accounts. If federal preemption succeeds, prediction platforms could operate under uniform CFTC rules, which lack traditional state-level consumer protections, local licensing requirements, and state-mandated responsible gaming controls.

If state authority is preserved, platforms offering sports or political wagers must continue complying with individual state laws. Users should note that state regulators maintain that local gambling laws remain active and enforceable within state borders.

When to Speak With an Attorney

If you face legal questions regarding online betting rules, account restrictions on prediction platforms, or state gaming compliance, consulting a lawyer can help clarify your rights. An attorney specializing in administrative law or gaming regulations can explain how shifting state and federal rules affect your situation.

What this means: our conclusions

1 Risk1 What to watch1 Context1 What to do
  1. RiskState Gaming Controls Face Federal Challenge

    If the CFTC rules take effect, prediction market platforms could bypass state responsible gaming rules and local consumer protections.

  2. What to watchSupreme Court Review May Decide Authority

    With New Jersey petitioning the Supreme Court, the high court could clarify whether federal financial rules override state gambling enforcement.

  3. ContextFederal Courts Support State Regulation

    Most federal courts considering prediction markets have rejected claims that peer-to-peer sports betting is exempt from state laws.

  4. What to doCheck State Rules Before Using Prediction Apps

    Users should check local state laws and licensing status before depositing funds on sports or election prediction platforms.

Comparison of CFTC Rules on Gambling and Prediction Markets
CFTC RuleStatusTreatment of Gambling ProductsImpact on State Powers
Interim RuleCurrently in effectExcludes house-backed casino games from swap definitionDoes not classify house-backed games as financial swaps
Proposed RuleProposed (not in effect)Expands swap definition to cover peer-to-peer sports and election betsClaims federal CFTC regulation displaces state gambling control

Source: New Jersey Attorney General

Related legal answers

Find a lawyer for this issue

Federal rules apply nationwide, but your options depend on your state and situation. Browse attorneys by practice area, then pick your state.

This article is general information based on New Jersey Attorney General and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 20, 2026.

Source: New Jersey Attorney General

More from Federal & Nationwide