image

Police recruit seeks revival of lawsuit over severe training injuries in Denver

Police recruit seeks revival of lawsuit over severe training injuries in Denver

Victor Moses, a former Denver police recruit, filed a petition with the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Nov. 17, 2026, asking the panel to revive his lawsuit against the Denver Police Department and paramedics. The suit stems from a “fight day” training exercise on Jan. 6, 2023, that left Moses catastrophically injured, hospitalized for four months, and ultimately resulted in the amputation of both legs below the knee.

What happened during the training?

During the “fight day” drill, recruits are subjected to simulated violent assaults. Moses, who has sickle cell trait and is prone to medical complications, says instructors urged him to continue even after he became fatigued and passed out. Paramedics cleared him to keep training, and he later developed a drug‑resistant infection that required multiple surgeries and dialysis.

Chronology of Moses’s case
  1. Injury occurs during Denver police "fight day" training
  2. Moses files lawsuit against Denver and paramedics
  3. District judge dismisses two federal claims, remands others
  4. 10th Circuit hearing on petition to revive case

Source: Courthouse News Service

Legal claims and lower‑court rulings

Moses sued the city and county of Denver in 2024, alleging violations of his rights to be free from excessive force and conscience‑shocking government conduct. In 2025, U.S. District Judge Gordon Gallagher dismissed two federal claims and sent the remaining claims back to state court. Moses appealed, arguing the judge gave undue deference to Denver and failed to accept his factual allegations.

Arguments before the 10th Circuit

During the hearing, civil‑rights attorney David Kilmer argued that Moses lost the ability to consent once he passed out, likening him to a concussed athlete. The panel questioned why Moses was allowed to continue training after expressing a desire to do so. Denver’s attorney Kristin Arthur framed the incident as an employment injury, emphasizing that officers used force to train, not to restrain. Paramedic‑defense lawyer Todd Drake contended that the care provided was negligent, not a case of deliberate indifference.

What this means for ordinary people

Anyone who participates in high‑risk training programs—whether in law enforcement, firefighting, or similar fields—should be aware that injuries sustained during such drills may raise constitutional and personal‑injury claims. Victims should document any medical warnings, fatigue, or instructions to continue despite health concerns. While the 10th Circuit has not yet ruled, the case highlights the importance of seeking immediate medical evaluation and legal counsel when injuries occur in training environments.

Consulting an attorney early can help preserve evidence and assess whether a claim for excessive force, negligence, or constitutional violations is viable.

What this means: our conclusions

1 Good news1 Risk2 What to watch1 What to do
  1. What to watchPotential shift in training liability

    If the 10th Circuit revives the case, police academies may need stricter medical‑clearance protocols, benefiting trainees who face health risks.

  2. Good newsConsent limits under the Fourth Amendment

    The court’s view on consent after a trainee passes out could broaden constitutional protections for employees in dangerous training.

  3. RiskEmployers may face increased negligence claims

    Denver’s argument that the incident is merely an employment injury may be challenged, prompting other agencies to reassess training safety.

  4. What to doWhat injured trainees should do now

    Document all medical advice, training instructions, and any signs of fatigue; consider consulting a lawyer promptly to preserve rights.

  5. What to watchUncertainty remains on the final outcome

    The panel has not set a decision date, leaving the legal status of Moses’s claims unresolved for now.

Key positions of parties in the appeal
PartyPosition
Victor Moses (plaintiff)Alleges excessive force, loss of consent, constitutional violation
Denver Police Dept. & city/countyFrames incident as employment injury, argues no unconstitutional seizure
ParamedicsDefend actions as negligence, not deliberate indifference

Source: Courthouse News Service

This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 17, 2026.

Source: Courthouse News Service

More from Colorado

Find a lawyer in Colorado

Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in Colorado by practice area.