image

10th Circuit asked to revisit Denver affordable‑housing fees that force developers to sell units below market value

ColoradoReal Estate & Property
10th Circuit asked to revisit Denver affordable‑housing fees that force developers to sell units below market value

On November 16, 2026, a Colorado developer identified as redT asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit to reinstate its challenge to Denver’s affordable‑housing program. The program forces developers to either pay linkage fees or set aside 10% of a new project for long‑term affordable units.

The city’s ordinance imposes fees of $1.99 to $7.22 per square foot. RedT says the fees would total $24,962 for one four‑plex and $44,917 for another, or the developer must give up a portion of the units at below‑market prices for 99 years.

What the Denver ordinance requires

Denver’s council created a “linkage fee” system to fund affordable housing. Developers can avoid the fee by dedicating one‑tenth of a project to units sold at reduced prices for nearly a century. The fee range translates into thousands of dollars for typical multifamily projects.

Key events in the Denver affordable‑housing dispute
  1. redT files lawsuit against Denver over linkage‑fee ordinance
  2. U.S. District Judge Philip Brimmer dismisses the case
  3. redT asks 10th Circuit to revive its challenge

Source: Courthouse News Service

Legal arguments presented to the 10th Circuit

RedT argues the ordinance amounts to an unconstitutional taking of property. Pacific Legal Foundation attorney David Deerson says the city is effectively demanding a developer either surrender a unit or pay a large sum before a permit is issued. Judges on the panel, including appointees of Presidents George W. Bush and Donald Trump, questioned whether the rule deprives owners of the right to dispose of property.

City attorney Adam Hernandez described the ordinance as a permissible restrictive covenant, not a taking, and suggested the council could modify or stop enforcing it.

Potential impact on ordinary builders and homeowners

If the court upholds the ordinance, developers will continue to face either the fee or the affordable‑unit requirement, which could raise construction costs and affect housing prices. Homeowners building single‑family homes may also confront the same choice, according to the developer’s counsel.

There is no set timeline for a decision, and the lower‑court dismissal remains in place unless the appellate panel reverses it.

When consulting an attorney may help

Developers or property owners who receive a linkage‑fee notice or are asked to set aside affordable units should consider speaking with a real‑estate attorney to assess options and potential challenges.

What this means: our conclusions

1 Risk2 What to watch1 Context1 What to do
  1. What to watchUncertainty for developers

    Until the appellate court decides, developers may face higher costs or delays, which could slow new housing projects in Denver.

  2. RiskPotential cost shift to buyers

    If fees remain, developers might pass the expense to homebuyers, raising prices for ordinary families.

  3. ContextLegal test for land‑use restrictions

    The case could clarify how far municipalities can go in imposing affordable‑housing mandates without a taking claim.

  4. What to watchWatch for council action

    Denver could amend the ordinance to avoid litigation, but any change may come too late for projects already underway.

  5. What to doConsult a real‑estate lawyer

    Owners receiving a linkage‑fee notice should get legal advice promptly to explore exemptions or challenges.

Positions of the parties in the appeal
PartyPosition
redT (developer)Claims ordinance is an unconstitutional taking
City of DenverCalls ordinance a permissible restrictive covenant

Source: Courthouse News Service

Related legal answers

This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 17, 2026.

Source: Courthouse News Service

More from Colorado

Find a lawyer in Colorado

Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in Colorado by practice area.