
On Wednesday in San Francisco, a U.S. Circuit Judge interrupted an attorney representing two former city and county employees who argued their clients deserved back pay after being reinstated to their jobs following a dispute over COVID-19 vaccinations. Judge Ryan Nelson cut off the argument over back pay claims, describing it as an Occam’s razor issue and noting that the parties were getting ahead of themselves. Usually, an injunction does not address monetary damages, which can be handled later.
Attorney Russell Davis argued that the district court abused its discretion by failing to include back pay with the order for reinstatement, characterizing the money as restitution rather than damages. However, U.S. Circuit Judge Daniel Collins noted that the district court dismissed the issue without prejudice, suggesting the proper motion should be brought in the lower court. San Francisco Deputy City Attorney Adam Shapiro stated that the city and county were not opposed to the workers seeking back pay, though it would ultimately require a jury’s decision.
The ongoing religious discrimination case stems from a 2021 mandate requiring all 35,000 city and county of San Francisco employees to receive a COVID-19 vaccination. In March 2022, Selina Keene, Melody Fountila, and another employee filed a complaint stating they were wrongfully denied religious exemptions because the vaccines used stem cells harvested from aborted fetuses during development, which contradicted their Christian beliefs. A federal judge initially rejected the lawsuit in September 2022, ruling the claims were based on personal preference rather than religious grounds. A separate Ninth Circuit panel later overturned that dismissal, finding the lower judge made factual errors.
During Wednesday’s arguments, Shapiro noted that the employees had been offered reinstatement to their former positions but declined to take them, arguing the record was convoluted and could be viewed as rejecting the jobs. Davis pushed back, stating the language amounted to rehiring at a lower income level without seniority. Judge Nelson questioned why Davis did not point out any potential violation of the injunction to the lower court if the positions were not properly reinstated, telling him that he came up to the appeals court for relief he never asked for.
Source: Courthouse News Service
Workers involved in employment disputes over workplace mandates must ensure they follow the correct procedural steps when pursuing monetary relief such as back pay. Appellate courts generally expect monetary remedies like back pay or restitution to be raised and properly requested through motions in the district court before seeking review at the appellate level. Employees facing similar disputes should document all employment terms, including salary and seniority status upon any offered reinstatement, to prevent disagreements over whether an offer meets prior employment conditions.
As this litigation demonstrates, navigating employment discrimination claims and associated financial remedies often requires detailed adherence to court rules and ongoing trial proceedings. Anyone dealing with workplace mandate disputes or complex reinstatement offers may benefit from consulting an employment attorney to evaluate their options and file the correct motions within the trial court.
The panel's questions signal that appellate courts will not bypass trial courts to award monetary remedies like back pay in the first instance.
Municipal attorneys indicate that back pay claims must be decided by a jury, adding steps and time for workers seeking financial recovery.
Disputes over whether a job offer constitutes true reinstatement or a demotion can complicate litigation and damage recovery efforts.
Affected workers seeking back pay should file the correct specific motions in the trial court rather than raising new relief on appeal.
| Party | Position on Back Pay and Reinstatement |
|---|---|
| Employees | Argue back pay is restitution and should have accompanied reinstatement. |
| City and County | State back pay requires a jury decision and note jobs were declined. |
| Ninth Circuit | Indicated monetary claims should be brought via district court motions. |
Source: Courthouse News Service
This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 19, 2026.
Source: Courthouse News Service
A three‑judge panel of the Ninth Circuit upheld a lower court ruling that the 2021 Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act applies, keeping eight former SpaceX employees' harassment claims in court.
The Ninth Circuit upheld a preliminary injunction, leaving California's 2024 law that bars forced political or religious all‑hands meetings unenforced.
Lyft will pay more than $272 million to resolve California claims it misclassified drivers, with about $237 million earmarked for eligible drivers.
Lyft will pay $272.5 million to resolve claims that it misclassified thousands of drivers as independent contractors rather than employees.
Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in California by practice area.