image

Florida Attorney General Sues Hospital Rating Group Over Low Safety Scores

FloridaBusiness & Corporate
Florida Attorney General Sues Hospital Rating Group Over Low Safety Scores

On November 20, 2026, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed a lawsuit against The Leapfrog Group and its President and CEO, Leah Binder. The state alleges that the national hospital-rating nonprofit misled Florida patients by claiming its hospital safety grades were peer-reviewed and expert-guided, while secretly giving low scores to hospitals that did not complete its voluntary surveys.

According to the complaint, filed in the Circuit Court of the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit in Seminole County, the organization publishes letter grades for roughly 190 Florida hospitals twice a year. The lawsuit claims that when hospitals declined to participate in voluntary surveys, Leapfrog assigned them the worst scores in the country without underlying data on certain measures. The state alleges these actions violated the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act and Florida’s Solicitation of Contributions Act.

Revenue Goals and Altered Scoring Methods

The state’s legal action details how financial pressures allegedly influenced the ratings. In 2024, facing a projected revenue shortfall of about $540,000, CEO Leah Binder reportedly adopted a new scoring method. Beginning with the Fall 2024 grades, non-surveyed hospitals received the lowest possible scores on four measures, and the weight of those measures increased from 24 percent to 31 percent of a hospital’s overall grade. Internal messages cited in the complaint indicate staff knew the scores were being assigned arbitrarily.

While this scoring change was implemented, survey participation rose from 64 percent to 79 percent. Additionally, Leapfrog sold “accolade” licenses to hospitals for $6,700 to $29,900 a year, allowing facilities to advertise their grades. These license sales reached a record of more than $4 million in fiscal year 2025.

Key Figures from the Leapfrog Group Investigation
$4 millionRecord accolade sales in FY 2025
79%Survey participation after score change
$540,000Forecasted revenue shortfall in 2024
190Florida hospitals graded twice a year

Source: Florida Attorney General

Impact on Florida Patients

The complaint highlights specific instances where Florida residents relied on these disputed letter grades when making medical decisions. In one instance cited by the state, a West Boca Medical Center patient with a compound finger fracture left the facility against medical advice because family members read negative Leapfrog reviews online. Other patients expressed extreme fear of dying at hospitals that actually maintained outcomes significantly better than the national average, or refused necessary surgeries due to failing grades published by the nonprofit.

The lawsuit asks the court to permanently bar the defendants from misrepresenting their data and methods, order corrective disclosures to consumers and licensees, demand restitution and disgorgement, and impose civil penalties of up to $10,000 per willful violation—or up to $15,000 if a victim is a senior citizen. The Attorney General also filed an amicus brief in the Eleventh Circuit arguing that the First Amendment does not protect deceptive rating practices.

Video explainer: Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act — David Jaroszewski

What This Means for Consumers

For ordinary healthcare consumers, this case underscores the potential dangers of relying solely on online rating tools when making critical medical choices. Patients who refused medical care or selected hospitals based on the contested Leapfrog ratings may have been influenced by arbitrary metrics rather than actual clinical outcomes. If you are researching healthcare facilities, it can help to consult multiple official data sources, speak directly with your treating physicians about hospital quality metrics, and keep personal records of any healthcare decisions influenced by questionable public ratings.

Talking to a qualified attorney may help if you suffered measurable harm or distress due to deceptive commercial practices or misleading health data.

What this means: our conclusions

2 Risk2 What to watch1 What to do
  1. What to watchImpact on Healthcare Ratings

    This lawsuit highlights the risks of relying on voluntary, for-profit survey systems for critical medical choices, potentially pushing rating agencies toward greater transparency.

  2. RiskFinancial Motives Examined

    The state's focus on revenue shortfalls and rising accolade sales demonstrates how commercial interests can improperly influence consumer-facing safety scores.

  3. RiskPatient Trust and Safety

    Patients may have delayed or avoided necessary medical care based on arbitrary grades, illustrating real-world dangers from deceptive commercial practices.

  4. What to watchFirst Amendment Limits

    The related federal amicus filing tests the boundaries of free speech protections when nonprofit organizations publish misleading commercial evaluations.

  5. What to doCheck Multiple Sources

    Consumers should consult multiple official sources and discuss hospital quality directly with medical professionals rather than relying on a single rating website.

Overview of Enforcement Actions Sought by Florida Attorney General
Relief SoughtDetails
Injunctive ReliefPermanently bar misrepresenting data, sources, methods, or expert approvals
Charitable RegistrationBar Leapfrog from soliciting charitable contributions without a valid registration
Restitution & DisgorgementOrder funds returned to affected consumers, hospitals, insurers, and donors
Civil PenaltiesUp to $10,000 per willful violation; up to $15,000 if victim is a senior citizen

Source: Florida Attorney General

This article is general information based on Florida Attorney General and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 20, 2026.

Source: Florida Attorney General

More from Florida

Find a lawyer in Florida

Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in Florida by practice area.