image

DHS Seeks to End Injunction Requiring Immigration Arrest Assessments in Colorado

ColoradoImmigration
DHS Seeks to End Injunction Requiring Immigration Arrest Assessments in Colorado

On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) asked the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to lift a preliminary injunction that requires immigration agents to complete a flight‑risk and law‑violation assessment before detaining immigrants without a warrant in Colorado.

The injunction stems from a class‑action filed by Refugio Ramirez Ovando and three other plaintiffs on Oct. 9, 2025, challenging the government’s practice of warrantless arrests without the required assessments.

Government’s Argument to the Appeals Court

U.S. Attorney Daniel Mummolo told the panel that the district court’s order forces the court to monitor every warrantless immigration arrest in the state, which he said is an overreach. He argued that DHS is not required to produce evidence of compliance beyond its written policy.

Possible Next Steps in the Case
  1. 1DHS files brief asking the 10th Circuit to lift the injunction
  2. 2Court reviews arguments and may allow evidence of compliance later
  3. 3If injunction stays, agents must continue assessments and documentation
  4. 4If lifted, warrantless arrests could proceed without assessments

Source: Courthouse News Service

Plaintiffs’ Position and ACLU Involvement

Represented by ACLU attorney Timothy MacDonald, the plaintiffs asked the panel to keep the injunction in place, saying they must show a likelihood of success on the merits. They contend the government has not demonstrated that agents are following the assessment requirement.

Judges’ Questions Highlight Issues

During oral arguments, the judges raised practical concerns. Judge Harris Hartz asked whether agents are equipped with body cameras to document compliance. Judge Joel Carson pressed DHS to produce evidence that assessments are being performed. The panel’s discussion suggests the court may allow the government to present compliance evidence later in the case.

Video explainer: Imagine being held in an immigration detention facility and being put inside a metal enclosure — Brad Bernstein Law

What This Means for Immigrants and the Public

If the injunction is lifted, immigration agents in Colorado could resume warrantless arrests without completing the mandated assessment, potentially increasing the number of detentions without documented flight‑risk analysis. Immigrants who are detained may have fewer procedural safeguards. Those concerned should monitor future court filings and consider keeping records of any detention experiences. While no specific deadline was mentioned, any changes will depend on the appellate court’s eventual decision.

Anyone facing detention or who believes their rights have been violated may benefit from consulting an attorney experienced in immigration law to assess options and protect their interests.

What this means: our conclusions

1 Risk2 What to watch1 Context1 What to do
  1. What to watchPotential Shift in Detention Practices

    If the injunction is removed, immigration agents may conduct warrantless arrests without documented risk assessments, affecting due‑process protections.

  2. RiskImmigrants Face Greater Uncertainty

    The change could increase the number of detentions without clear justification, raising concerns for immigrant communities in Colorado.

  3. ContextGovernment Relies on Policy Over Evidence

    DHS argues that written policy is enough, which may limit the court’s ability to verify actual compliance.

  4. What to watchWatch for the Appeals Court Decision

    The panel has not set a decision date; parties and observers should monitor filings for the next update.

  5. What to doConsider Legal Counsel

    Immigrants detained under the current or future rules should consult an immigration attorney to understand their rights and options.

Positions of Parties in the Appeal
PartyPosition
DHSSeeks to lift injunction, cites policy compliance
Plaintiffs/ACLUWant injunction upheld, demand proof of assessments

Source: Courthouse News Service

This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 17, 2026.

Source: Courthouse News Service

More from Colorado

Find a lawyer in Colorado

Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in Colorado by practice area.