image

Supreme Court Declines Challenge to California Implicit Bias Training Law

Supreme Court Declines Challenge to California Implicit Bias Training Law

The Supreme Court declined to take up a legal challenge against California regulations that require continuing medical education courses to cover implicit bias. The decision leaves intact lower court rulings that allowed the state to mandate the coursework for licensing instructors.

In a separate action, the justices also refused to review a Maryland law restricting where gun owners can carry firearms in public places. However, both orders drew comments from conservative justices regarding the legal limits of government authority under the First and Second Amendments.

First Amendment Dispute Over Medical Licensing Courses

The California case was brought by Azadeh Khatibi, an ophthalmologist who teaches continuing education, and Do No Harm, a nonprofit organization. They challenged a state requirement mandating that medical licensing courses include instruction on how implicit bias contributes to unequal treatment and healthcare disparities.

Two lower courts, including a federal appeals court, dismissed the lawsuit. They ruled that the state’s curriculum rules qualified as government speech, exempting them from First Amendment challenges. Justice Clarence Thomas dissented from the high court’s decision not to hear the appeal, joined by Justice Samuel Alito. Justice Neil Gorsuch also stated he would have granted the petition.

Thomas argued that the lower courts overextended government-speech protections to control private instructors. Expressing concern over compelled expression, Thomas wrote,

“We should not permit the government-speech doctrine to be wielded as ‘a cover for censorship’ or a cloak for compelled speech.”

He warned that such logic could allow states to force instructors to communicate preferred messages on controversial medical topics like abortion or gender-affirming surgery.

Key Issues in Supreme Court Rejections
California Healthcare Case
  • Mandated implicit bias content in courses
  • Ruled government speech by lower court
  • SCOTUS declined to review dissent issued
Maryland Firearms Case
  • Restricted guns in public sensitive areas
  • Challenged by local firearm owners
  • SCOTUS declined review due to broad scope

Source: Courthouse News Service

Judicial Concerns Over Sensitive-Place Gun Restrictions

The high court also turned down an appeal from gun owners challenging a Maryland statute. The Maryland law restricts firearms at public demonstrations, mass transit, amusement venues, healthcare facilities, state parks, forest land, and places that serve alcohol for onsite consumption.

Thomas agreed with turning down the Maryland appeal because the broad scope of the lawsuit made review complicated. However, he noted that the Supreme Court should address sensitive-place firearm restrictions in a future case. Thomas questioned whether historical legal traditions support broad bans enacted in states such as Maryland, California, New York, and New Jersey.

What the Rulings Mean for Professionals and the Public

For healthcare professionals in California, continuing medical education providers must continue to include implicit bias training in their licensing programs. Because the Supreme Court declined to review the lower court decisions, the state’s educational requirements remain in full effect for instructors and attendees.

For firearm owners, public carry restrictions in Maryland and similar states remain legally enforceable. While conservative justices indicated an interest in reviewing sensitive-place firearm bans in future litigation, existing state laws prohibiting weapons in specified public locations continue to apply.

When to Consult a Lawyer

Individuals or licensed professionals facing state compliance requirements, administrative rules, or public carry restrictions should consult a qualified attorney. A legal expert can help clarify local licensing standards, constitutional rights, and state-specific regulations.

What this means: our conclusions

3 What to watch1 Context1 What to do
  1. What to watchCalifornia Medical Bias Mandate Remains Enforceable

    Continuing medical education providers and healthcare workers in California must continue complying with state requirements that incorporate implicit bias coursework.

  2. What to watchFirst Amendment Debate on Professional Speech Continues

    The dissent by conservative justices signals potential future scrutiny over how far states can go when mandating specific instruction in regulated professions.

  3. ContextMaryland Public Carry Rules Remain in Effect

    Gun owners in Maryland must abide by state prohibitions on carrying firearms in specified sensitive areas like transit, parks, and healthcare venues.

  4. What to watchFuture Scrutiny Expected for Sensitive-Place Gun Bans

    Although the Supreme Court rejected this broad firearm appeal, justices indicated a willingness to examine similar restrictions in a narrower future case.

  5. What to doVerify State-Specific Professional and Carry Standards

    Licensed professionals and gun owners should monitor state regulatory updates and consult legal counsel regarding legal compliance in their jurisdiction.

Summary of Supreme Court Supreme Court Petition Actions
Case SubjectChallenged State LawSupreme Court ActionJustice Comments
Implicit Bias Medical TrainingCalifornia requirement for continuing medical educationPetition DeniedThomas dissented (joined by Alito); Gorsuch favored review
Public Carry Firearm RestrictionsMaryland ban in sensitive areas (transit, parks, venues)Petition DeniedThomas supported denial due to scope, called for future case review

Source: Courthouse News Service

Find a lawyer for this issue

Federal rules apply nationwide, but your options depend on your state and situation. Browse attorneys by practice area, then pick your state.

This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 16, 2026.

Source: Courthouse News Service

More from Federal & Nationwide