
The Minnesota Supreme Court heard arguments Thursday regarding whether negative online reviews of businesses should receive heightened free-speech protections. The case centers on a dispute between a contractor, Paragon Restorations LLC, and a video production company, Robinet Productions LLC, following a failed commercial contract.
After Paragon allegedly refused to pay for promotional video work, the owner of Robinet posted a one-star Google review. The review stated that the company was denied payment and encouraged others to avoid doing business with Paragon. Paragon subsequently sued for defamation, arguing the review was false because the production company failed to meet its contract obligations.
Robinet sought to dismiss the lawsuit using Minnesota’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act. This law is an anti-SLAPP statute, which stands for “strategic lawsuits against public participation.” These laws are designed to protect critics from baseless lawsuits intended to silence them through the high costs of litigation. If a court grants an anti-SLAPP motion, the case is fast-tracked, and the plaintiff may be required to pay the defendant’s attorney fees and litigation expenses.
However, the act does not apply to every dispute. It is limited to “matters of public concern.” A lower court previously dismissed the defamation claim, finding the statement about unpaid work to be technically true, but it did not apply the anti-SLAPP act. Consequently, Robinet was unable to recover attorney fees. The Minnesota Court of Appeals later upheld this, ruling that the review was a personal grievance rather than a matter of public concern.
Source: Courthouse News Service
Attorneys for both sides presented conflicting views on how the law should apply to consumer commentary. Robinet’s attorney argued that the review served as a warning to other potential customers, fulfilling the law’s intent to broaden free speech. Conversely, Paragon’s counsel argued that the review was merely an expression of anger over a private transaction and that labeling all business reviews as matters of public concern would overstep the court’s constitutional role.
The justices expressed skepticism regarding how to define “public concern.” Justice Karl Procaccini questioned whether a test that relies on the popularity of a statement might unfairly disadvantage unpopular opinions. Justice Paul Thissen noted that while many people are harmed by defamation suits, the legislature may have intended for the anti-SLAPP act to protect only the highest levels of constitutional speech.
For ordinary people, this case highlights the risks of posting negative business reviews online. If the court rules that such reviews do not constitute a matter of public concern, reviewers may remain vulnerable to defamation claims without the protection of anti-SLAPP laws. This can leave individuals responsible for their own legal costs even if they believe their review is truthful.
If you are involved in a dispute over an online review, it is important to keep documentation of your interactions and the basis for your claims. If you are sued for defamation, speaking with an attorney early can help you understand whether your speech might qualify for protection under state law and how to manage the litigation process.
The court's eventual definition of 'public concern' will determine whether everyday consumer complaints are protected by law or remain open to litigation.
Without anti-SLAPP protection, individuals sued for defamation may face significant legal bills even if their statements are factually accurate.
If you post a negative review, keep clear records of your business interactions to support your claims should you face a legal challenge.
If you are sued for defamation based on an online review, consult an attorney immediately to evaluate potential defenses and anti-SLAPP eligibility.
| Court Level | Ruling on Anti-SLAPP |
|---|---|
| Lower Court | Did not apply the act |
| Court of Appeals | Ruled it was a private grievance |
| Supreme Court | Currently under review |
Source: Courthouse News Service
This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published November 5, 2026.
Source: Courthouse News Service
A coalition of anti-abortion groups is asking a federal appeals court to overturn a lower court ruling that dismissed their challenge to Minnesota’s abortion laws.
The Justice Department charged 13 defendants in Minnesota for schemes that cost the government nearly $83 million, including $29 million in newly uncovered fraud.
Minnesota urged a federal judge to throw out a lawsuit challenging its first-of-its-kind social media warning label law.
An insurance company asks the Minnesota high court to hold Amazon accountable for a 2018 building fire caused by a defective phone battery sold on its site.
Two Minnesota men pleaded guilty to wire fraud after submitting over $500,000 in false claims to a state housing assistance program for vulnerable people.
No attorneys in Minnesota are listed in our directory yet. Lawyers are licensed state by state, so before hiring, check that the attorney is admitted to practice in Minnesota.