Supreme Court to weigh Colorado preschool funding clash with Catholic schools over LGBTQ admissions
On Tuesday, the U.S. Supreme Court will consider a case that pits Colorado’s universal preschool program against two Catholic preschools that refuse to enroll children of LGBTQ families. The schools – St. Mary Catholic Parish in Littleton and St. Bernadette Catholic Parish in Lakewood – argue they are being excluded from a program that offers every four‑year‑old up to 15 hours of free preschool, worth more than $6,000 a year.
What the program requires
Colorado’s law provides free preschool to all eligible children, but schools that receive the funds must meet state quality standards and be open to all families. The Department of Early Childhood says the Catholic schools are being held to the same neutral standards that apply to public, secular and other private providers.
- 1Court rules in favor of the Catholic schools – more religious exemptions may be allowed
- 2Court upholds Colorado’s neutral rule – current nondiscrimination standards stay in place
- 3State may adjust program guidelines to address both religious liberty and LGBTQ inclusion
Source: Courthouse News Service
Legal background and the schools’ claim
The preschools cite recent Supreme Court decisions – Trinity Lutheran (2017), Espinoza (2020) and Carson v. Makin (2022) – that expanded the free‑exercise clause to prevent states from excluding religious institutions from generally available public benefits. They contend that Colorado’s requirement not to discriminate based on parents’ sexual orientation violates those precedents.
State’s defense
Colorado argues the program’s nondiscrimination rule is a neutral condition of participation, not a religious exclusion. The state urges the Court to apply Employment Division v. Smith, which allows generally applicable laws to be enforced even if they incidentally burden religious practice.
What this means for families
If the Court sides with the Catholic schools, other religious providers could seek exemptions from nondiscrimination requirements, potentially limiting access for LGBTQ families in publicly funded programs. Parents who rely on the preschool subsidy should monitor the case and be prepared for possible changes in eligibility rules. No specific deadlines are mentioned, but the decision could affect enrollment for the upcoming school year.
Anyone unsure how this ruling might impact their child’s preschool options should consider consulting an attorney who specializes in education or civil rights law.
What this means: our conclusions
- What to watchPotential shift in how religious schools access public funds
If the Court expands Carson, more faith‑based providers may seek exemptions, changing the landscape of publicly funded early education.
- RiskLGBTQ families could face reduced options
A decision that permits religious exemptions may limit preschool choices for families with LGBTQ parents in Colorado and possibly elsewhere.
- ContextState’s nondiscrimination rule under scrutiny
Colorado’s reliance on Smith highlights a clash between neutral laws and religious liberty claims, a tension likely to appear in future cases.
- What to watchLegal precedent may broaden religious exemptions
The justices’ interpretation could set a precedent that influences other states’ funding programs and anti‑discrimination policies.
- What to doConsult an attorney if you rely on preschool subsidies
Parents should talk to a lawyer to understand how a ruling could affect their child’s enrollment and any possible appeals.
This article is general information based on Courthouse News Service and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published October 30, 2026.
Source: Courthouse News Service
Supreme Court poised to rule on Colorado preschool rule affecting Catholic schools
The high court heard arguments on whether Colorado can require Catholic preschools in its universal program to accept all children, including LGBTQ families, without a religious exemption.
Supreme Court to Hear Catholic Preschools’ Religious Discrimination Claim in Colorado
The high court will hear arguments on Nov. 3 about whether Colorado must exempt Catholic preschools from a nondiscrimination rule that includes LGBTQ families.
Supreme Court weighs whether federal Clean Air Act overrides Colorado climate lawsuit
The high court heard arguments on whether the Clean Air Act preempts Colorado's consumer‑protection claim against Exxon Mobil and Suncor, with eight justices hearing the case.
Find a lawyer in Colorado
Reading about the law is one thing, applying it to your own case is another. Browse verified attorneys in Colorado by practice area.