
On Sept. 29, 2026 the U.S. Supreme Court granted an emergency stay that lets the Trump administration continue sending non‑citizens to so‑called “third‑country” destinations. The Court gave no explanation and kept the case on its docket for a full hearing in December.
The dispute began in spring 2025 when a federal district court in Boston, presided over by Judge Brian E. Murphy, issued a preliminary injunction blocking removals to countries not listed in the alien’s order of removal. The injunction required the government to provide written notice and a meaningful opportunity for the alien to raise a fear‑of‑torture claim under the Convention Against Torture (CAT).
Federal law, 8 U.S.C. § 1231(b)(2)(E), lists the countries to which a non‑citizen may be removed – the country of admission, citizenship, birth, etc. Only when removal to each listed country is “impracticable, inadvisable, or impossible” may the government send a person to “another country whose government will accept the alien.” The statute makes this last‑resort category narrow, not a routine option.
Sending people from Venezuela or Honduras to places like Guatemala or South Sudan, where they have no prior contact, cannot speak the language, and may face torture or death, appears to run afoul of both the statutory text and international obligations under CAT. The district court had found the practice illegal and likely to cause great harm.
For now, the administration may keep deporting individuals to third countries without the required notice or CAT hearing. Anyone who receives a removal order to a third country should verify whether they were given written notice and an opportunity to argue a fear of torture. No specific deadline is mentioned in the stay, but the Supreme Court will hear arguments in December, and the stay remains in effect until a final decision.
People facing a third‑country removal should consider consulting an immigration attorney promptly to ensure their procedural rights are protected and to explore any possible relief.
Until the Supreme Court issues a final ruling, the administration can keep sending migrants to distant nations, increasing risk for those individuals.
Non‑citizens still have the right to notice and a chance to claim fear of torture before removal, even under the stay.
The Court’s briefing and oral arguments in December will determine the long‑term legality of third‑country removals.
If the Court ultimately upholds the stay, the government may expand third‑country removals to more nations.
People facing a third‑country removal should consult an immigration lawyer to protect their CAT rights and explore relief options.
Federal rules apply nationwide, but your options depend on your state and situation. Browse attorneys by practice area, then pick your state.
This article is general information based on SCOTUSblog and court or agency records available at publication time. It is not legal advice; laws and deadlines differ by state and by case. Published October 6, 2026.
Source: SCOTUSblog
The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to block a ruling keeping Temporary Protected Status for Venezuelans, then withdrew the request.
A private security firm contracted to transport detained immigrant children has agreed to pay $48.75 million to resolve a class-action lawsuit.
The Trump administration seeks a third emergency ruling from the Supreme Court to stop a lower court order that could restore TPS for up to 350,000 Venezuelan migrants.
The high court will decide if the 2025 proclamation that halted asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border and related DHS guidance violate federal immigration law.
The Supreme Court is considering whether the government can use administrative judges to penalize employers who violate H-2A farm labor program rules.