How is property divided in a divorce?

Step one: marital or separate?

Courts first classify every asset and debt. Marital (or community) property generally includes everything either spouse acquired during the marriage, no matter whose name is on it: income, homes, cars, retirement contributions, businesses started during the marriage, and debts taken on for the family. Separate property usually includes what a spouse owned before the marriage, gifts and inheritances received individually, and personal injury awards for pain and suffering. A valid prenuptial or postnuptial agreement can change these rules.

Community property states

Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington and Wisconsin treat marital property as owned equally by both spouses. California, Louisiana and New Mexico generally require an equal split in value; the others divide community property in a way that is “just and right” or equitable, which usually but not always means equal. Alaska, Tennessee, Kentucky and South Dakota let couples opt into community property by agreement.

Equitable distribution states

The other 41 states and the District of Columbia divide marital property equitably — fairly in light of the circumstances. Judges consider factors such as:

• The length of the marriage.
• Each spouse's income, earning capacity, age and health.
• Contributions to the marriage, including homemaking and child care.
• Contributions to the other spouse's education or career.
• Who will have custody of the children and need the family home.
• Waste or hiding of marital assets.
• Tax consequences of the division.

In long marriages the result is often close to 50/50; in short marriages or unequal circumstances it can differ significantly.

Mixed and changed property

Separate property can become partly marital. If a spouse deposits an inheritance into a joint account and uses it for family expenses, it may be “commingled” and lose its separate character. If a house owned before marriage is paid down with marital income or improved with marital funds, the increase in value may be divided. Tracing records — bank statements showing where money came from — are the key evidence.

Watch

Common assets and how they are handled

• The family home — sold and the proceeds split, kept by one spouse who buys out the other's share, or occasionally kept jointly until children finish school.
• Retirement accounts and pensions — the marital portion is divided, usually through a qualified domestic relations order (QDRO) that avoids early-withdrawal penalties.
• Businesses — valued by an expert; the owning spouse usually keeps the business and compensates the other with other assets or payments.
• Debts — marital debts are divided as well, though creditors can still collect from anyone whose name is on the account.
• Pets — legally property in most states, but a few, including Alaska, California and Illinois, let courts consider the animal's well-being.

Valuation date and taxes

States differ on whether assets are valued at separation, filing or trial, which matters for investments that rise or fall. Transfers between spouses as part of a divorce are generally not taxable, but the recipient inherits the tax basis — so $100,000 in a 401(k) is worth less after tax than $100,000 in cash.

Protecting yourself

Collect statements for every account, loan and asset before or early in the case. Do not move, hide or spend down assets: courts can penalize dissipation, and many states impose automatic orders freezing major transactions once a divorce is filed. Where significant property is at stake, a family lawyer and, if needed, a financial expert or forensic accountant usually pay for themselves.

Can we divide it ourselves?

Yes. Spouses are free to agree on any division they both accept, and courts approve most such agreements without changing them. A negotiated split can account for things a court might not, such as one spouse's attachment to the house or the other's preference for liquid assets. The agreement should list every asset and debt, state who receives each, set deadlines for refinancing and transfers, and say who is responsible for taxes on sales. Vague terms are the most common cause of disputes after a divorce is final.